The Emergence of a Security Approach to Climate Change Governance: prospects and challenges to enhance environmental security in Brazil and the global south



This article aims to explore the intersection between human security and climate change security agendas. It is inquired in which ways a climate change security approach impairs multilateral official channels aimed to enhance the global south demands, especially regarding the sustainable development imperatives. Further, it is investigated how the radicalization of the climate change action with a special focus at the Amazon, may oppose a human-rights-based approach enhanced at the UN 2030 Agenda.

Biografia do Autor

Tatiana Waisberg, University of Haifa

PhD researcher, Law faculty.


Allo, Awol K. “The ICC’s problem is not overt racism, it is Eurocentricism.” Aljazeera, 28 Jul 2018. <>

Ambos, Kai and Aboueldahab, Susam. “Colombia: Time for the ICC Prosecutor to Act?” EJIL Talk! April 2, 2019 <>

Assad, Eduardo D., et. al. “Climate Change Challenges for Brazil. Climate change, sustainable development, and human security: a comparative analysis.” Edited by Dhirendra K. Vajpeyi. Lanham : Lexington Books, 169-200, 2013.

Atapattu, Sumudu. “Climate Change, International Environmental Law Principles, and the North-South Divide.” Transnational Law & Contemporary Problems, Summer 2017, Vol.26(2), (2017): 247-261

Atkins, Ed.” Belo Monte: there is nothing green or sustainable about these mega-dams.” The Conversation. August 9, 2018 <>

Barret, O. et. Al. “Climate and Security in Brazil.” Product of the Expert Group of the International Military Council on Climate and Security. Edited by Francesco Femia and Shiloh Fetzek. Published by the Center for Climate and Security, an institute of the Council on Strategic Risks. November 2020.

Barreto, José-Manuel. “Epistemologies of the South and Human Rights: Santos and the Quest for Global and Cognitive Justice.” Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies, Vol.21(2), (2014): 395-422

Barbieri, A., et al 2010. "Climate change and population migration in Brazil’s Northeast: scenarios for 2025–2050." Population and Environment 31(5), (2010): 344-70.

Basilio, Ana Luiza. “Cacique eleito prefeito no sertão pernambucano luta pela posse no TSE 'Negar sua eleição seria criminalizar, mais uma vez, o povo Xucuru', diz presidente de associação indígena.” Carta Capital, 14 de dezembro de 2020 <>

BBC. “EU carbon neutrality: Leaders agree 2050 target without Poland.” BBC News. 13 December 2019 <>

Biggeri, M., & Ferrannini, A. Sustainable Human Development: A New Territorial and People-centred Perspective., Palgrave: New York, 2014.

Brock, Hanna. “Climate Change: Drivers of Insecurity and the Global South.” Oxford Research Group. June 2012. <>

Boadle, A. “Brazil pledge on Amazon needed to save EU-Mercosur trade deal -EU diplomat.” Reuters, December 2, 2020 <>

Bowcott, Owen. “International lawyers draft plan to criminalise ecosystem destruction. Plan to draw up legal definition of ‘ecocide’ attracts support from European countries and small island nations.” The Guardian, 30 Nov 2020. <>

Brunnee, Jutta. Climate change, global environmental justice and international environmental law. Environmental law and justice in context . Edited by Jonas Ebbesson and Phoebe Okowa, 316-332. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 2009.

Bugge, Hans Christian. The polluter pays principle: dilemmas of justice in national and international contexts. Environmental law and justice in context. Edited by Jonas Ebbesson and Phoebe Okowa. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 2009.

Caney, Simon. “Cosmopolitan Justice, Responsibility, and Global Climate Change.” Leiden Journal of International Law 18, no. 4 (2005): 747–75.

Capellini, N., Castro, M. C., & Gutjahr, E. (2011). Patterns of environmental migration in Brazil: Three case studies. In F. Gemenne, P. Br¨ucker, & J. Glaser (Eds.), The state of environmental migration. Paris: IDDRI Sciences Po and IOM, (2010): 87–110.

Carmo, F. et. al. “Fundão tailings dam failures: the environment tragedy of the largest technological disaster of Brazilian mining in global context.” Perspectives in Ecology and Conservation,Volume 15, Issue 3, (2017): 145-151

Casella, Paulo Borba. “Denúncia contra Bolsonaro no Tribunal Penal Internacional pode não ser acatada. Paulo Borba Casella explica que o Tribunal Internacional pode alegar foco em crimes relacionados a conflitos armados e não prosseguir com a denúncia.” Jornal da USP, 29/07/2020 <>

CIDH. Povo Indígena Xucuru Vs Brasil. 2018. Disponível em:

CIMI. Povo Xukuru recebe indenização do governo após sentença da CIDH que condenou o Estado por violações de direitos humanos. . 11/02/2020 <>

Cowell, Frederic. “Inherent Imperialism: Understanding the Legal Roots of Anti-imperialist Criticism of the International Criminal Court.” Journal of International Criminal Justice, Volume 15, Issue 4, September 2017, (2017): 667–687.

Dehm, Julia. “Carbon Colonialism or Climate Justice: Interrogating the International Climate Regime from a TWAIL Perspective.” 33 Windsor Y.B. Access Just. 129, (2016): 129-161.

Delgado-Ramos, Gian Carlo. Climate Change and the Urban Political Ecology of Water. Delgado, Gian Carlo, and Codesria. Inequality and Climate Change : Perspectives From the South, 103-120, Dakar, Senegal : Codesria, 2015.

Ebbesson, Jonas. Introduction: dimensions of justice in environmental law. Environmental law and justice in context . Edited by Jonas Ebbesson and Phoebe Okowa. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press 2009

Fainguelernt, Maíra Borges. “The Historical Trajectory of The Belo Monte Hydroelectric Plant's Environmental Licensing Process.” Ambiente & Sociedade, 19(2), (2016): 245-264

Friedman, Lisa. “What Is the Green New Deal? A Climate Proposal, Explained.” New York Times, Feb, 21, 2019 < >

Fukuda-Parr, S. “From the Millennium Development Goals to the Sustainable Development Goals: Shifts in Purpose, Concept, and Politics of Global Goal Setting for Development.” Gender & Development, 24(1), (2016): 43–52.

Fedi, Henrico. “Environmental’ catastrophes: an overview of the power relations behind the Mariana Dam Disaster in Brazil.” LSE Blog. June, 11, 2020.


Freedman, Andrew. “Amazon fires could accelerate global warming and cause lasting harm to a cradle of biodiversity.” The Washington Post. August 22, 2019. <>

Fetzek, et. al. “Climate Security and the Strategic Energy Pathway in Southeast Asia: Part of the ‘World Climate and Security Report 2020’ Briefer Series.” Edited by Erin Sikorsky and Francesco Femia. Published by the Center for Climate and Security (CCS), an institute of the Council on Strategic Risks (CSR). February 2021

Fetzek, et. al. “Climate and Security in the Indo-Asia Pacific 2020.” Product of the Expert Group of the International Military Council on Climate and Security. Edited by Francesco Femia & Caitlin Werrell. Published by the Center for Climate and Security, an institute of the Council on Strategic Risks. July 2020.

Gatehouse, Gabriel. “Deforested parts of Amazon 'emitting more CO2 than they absorb.” BBC Newsnight. 11 February, 2020. <>

Gonzalez, Carmen G. “Climate Justice and Climate Displacement: Evaluating the Emerging Legal and Policy Responses.” Wisconsin International Law Journal. Vol. 36, No. 2 Climate Justice and Climate Displacement. (2019): 366-396.

Gormezano, David. “The Mariana mining tragedy: Brazil's 'worst environmental disaster’.” France24, 26/01/2016. <>

Greene, Anastacia. “The Campaign to Make Ecocide an International Crime: Quixotic Quest or Moral Imperative?” (January 4, 2019). Fordham Environmental Law Journal, Vol. 30, No. 3, (2019): 1-48

Grisafi, Lily. “Prosecuting International Environmental Crime Committed Against Indigenous Peoples in Brazil.” HRLR Online. November 10, 2020. <>

Hardoy, J. and Pandiella, G. “Urban poverty and vulnerability to climate change in Latin America.” Environment and Urbanization. 21, (2009): 203-224

Harper, K., and Rajan, S. R. “International Environmental Justice: Building the Natural Assets of the World’s Poor.” Working Paper No. 87, Political Economy Research Institute, University of Massachusetts Amherst, (2004): 1-13.

Harvey, Chelsea. “Wildfires Could Transform Amazon from Carbon Sink to Source. Rising temperatures and increased deforestation increase the risks for CO2-emitting fires.” Scientific American. January 14, 2020.


Hecht, Susanna B; Cockburn, Alexander. The Fate of the Forest : Developers, Destroyers, and Defenders of the Amazon. Chicago : University of Chicago Press, 2011.

Henriksen, John B.” Research on Best Practices for the Implementation of the Principles of ILO Convention No. 169. Key Principles in Implementing ILO Convention No. 169.” 2008.

Hochstetler, Kathryn. “Climate Rights and Obligations for Emerging States: The Cases of Brazil and South Africa.” Social Research, Winter 2012, Vol.79(4), (2012): 957-982.

IACHR. Report No. 125/10. Petition 250-04. Admissibility. Raposa Serra Do Sol Indigenous Peoples V. Brazil, October 23, 2010.

IAtCH, 2010. PM 382/10 - Indigenous Communities of the Xingu River Basin, Pará, Brazil.

ICC. “ICC Prosecutor, Mrs Fatou Bensouda, receives high-level delegation from the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela in the context of its ongoing preliminary examinations.” Press Release, 5 November, 2020 <>

ILO. Convention 169 - Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention, 1989. <>

Ionesco, D. et al., The Atlas of Environmental Migration, Routledge/IOM, London and New York, 2017.

International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies Disasters in the Americas. “The case for legal preparedness.” Geneva, 2011. <>

Kadletz, Bruna. “Brazilian Tribe Fear Displacement by Xingu River’s Rising Tide.” The New Humanitarian, April 28, 2017. <>

Kamau, M., Chasek, P., and O’Connor, D. Transforming Multilateral Diplomacy: The Inside Story of the Sustainable Development Goals. New York: Routledge. 2018.

Köhler, G., Gasper, D., Jolly, R., & Simane, M. “Human Security and the Next Generation of Comprehensive Development Goals.” Journal of Human Security Studies, 1(2), (2012): 75–79.

Khadka, Navin Singh. “Amazon fires: Forest loss challenges Paris climate ambition.” BBC World Service, 28 August 2019. <>

Kjellen, Bo. “Justice in global environmental negotiations: the case of desertification. Environmental law and justice in context.” Edited by Jonas Ebbesson and Phoebe Okowa. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press. 2009.

Kälin, Walter. “The Nansen Initiative: building consensus on displacement in disaster contexts.” FMR 49, May 2015, p. 5-7. <>

Kellman, J. “The Brazilian Legal Tradition and Environmental Protection: Friend or Foe’” 25(2) Hastings International & Comparative Law Review, (2002): 145–67.

Lorraine, Elliott “Human security/environmental security”, Contemporary Politics, 21:1, (2015): 11-24.

Lonergan S. “Human Security, Environmental Security and Sustainable Development.” In: Lowi M.R., Shaw B.R. (eds) Environment and Security. International Political Economy Series. Palgrave Macmillan, London, 2000.

McAdam, Jane, “From the Nansen Initiative to the Platform on Disaster Displacement: Shaping International Approaches to Climate Change, Disasters and Displacement” University of New South Wales Law Journal, Vol. 39, No. 4, 2016, UNSW Law Research Paper No. 17, (2016): 4-17.

McGrath, Matt. “Large hydropower dams 'not sustainable' in the developing world. BBC News.” 5 November 2018. < >

Mehta, Sailesh and Merz, Prisca. “Ecocide – a new crime against peace?” Environmental Law Review, Vol. 17(1) (2015): 3–7.

Mickelson, Karin. “Competing narratives of justice in North–South environmental relations: the case of ozone layer depletion.” Environmental law and justice in context. Edited by Jonas Ebbesson and Phoebe Okowa. 297-315, Cambridge : Cambridge University Press 2009.

Mickelson, K., 2000. ‘South, North, International Environmental Law, and International Environmental Lawyers’. 11 Yearbook International Environmental Law 52. (2007): 52-81.

Milhorance, Flávia. “Jair Bolsonaro could face charges in The Hague over Amazon rainforest.” Guardian, Jan, 23, 2021. <>

Miner, Kimberley R. “Environmental Security Risks in South America.” October 29, 2019. <>

Mignolo, Walter . “The Geopolitics of Knowledge and the Colonial Difference,” The South Atlantic Quarterly 101 (2002), 59 & 63–74.

Mwanza, Rosemary. “Enhancing Accountability for Environmental Damage under International Law: Ecocide as a Legal Fulfilment of Ecological Integrity Enhancing Accountability for Environmental Damage.” Melbourne Journal of International Law. Vol. 19, (2018): 1-28.

Najam, S. “The View from the South: Developing Countries in Global Environmental Politics”, in Regina S. Axelrod, David Leonard Downie and Norman J. Vig (eds.), The Global Environment: Institutions, Law and Policy. 303-321, 2nd edn, Washington, DC: CQ Press, 2004.

Nash, S. L. , & Steurer, R. “Taking stock of climate change acts in Europe: Living policy processes or symbolic gestures?” Climate Policy , 19 (8), (2019): 1052–1065.

Navarro, Gabriela Cristina Braga. “The judgment of the case Xucuru People v. Brazil: InterAmerican Court of Human Rights between consolidation and setbacks.” Revista de Direito Internacional 16(2). November, (2019): 178-183.

O’Brien, Karen and Barnett, Jon. “Global Environmental Change and Human Security.” Annual Review of Environment and Resources. Vol. 38, (2013): 373-39.

OAS. 142 Periodic Session. On July 29, 2011, during its 142 regular session, the IACHR evaluated Precautionary Measure 382/10 at the regional meeting. < >

Okereke, Chukwumerije. “Moral Foundations for Global Environmental and Climate Justice.” Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement, 2011, Vol.69, (2011): 117-13.

Posner, Michael. "Reflections on the Vienna Conference on Human Rights." Proceedings of the Annual Meeting (American Society of International Law) 91 (1997): 317-21.

Ralf Oetzel, Ralf and Sergio Antonio Ruiz. “Movilidad humana, desastres naturales y cambio climático en América Latina: De la comprensión a la acción.” GIZ. (2017): 1-48.

Rajamani, L. “The Principle of Common But Differentiated Responsibility and the Balance of Commitments under the Climate Regime”. 9. Review of European Community and International Environmental Law 120, (2000): 120-134.

Roberts, J. T., and Parks, B. C. A Climate of Injustice, Global Inequality, North South Politics and Climate Policy. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2007.

Romero-Lankao, Patricia et. al. “Urban Vulnerability and Adaptation to the Health Impacts of Air Pollution and Climate Extremes in Latin American Cities.” Urban areas and global climate change. Edited by William G. Holt. Bingley, UK : Emerald, (2012): 247-275.

Santilli, Márcio. “Bolsonaro e as ‘ONGs’.” ISA. 22 de Outubro de 2020. <>

Santos, Boaventura de Sousa. “Epistemología del Sur.” Geograficando, 2018, Vol.14(1)

Sarlieve, Maud. “ICL and Environmental Protection Symposium: Which Future for the Crime of Ecocide?” Opinio Juris, 2020 <>

Shawkat Alam, Sumudu Atapattu, Carmen G. Gonzalez and Jona Razzaque (eds). International Environmental Law and the Global South. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015.

Shidore et. al. “Climate Security and the Strategic Energy Pathway in South Asia: Part of the ‘World Climate and Security Report 2020’ Briefer Series.” Edited by Erin Sikorsky (CCS) and Francesco Femia (CSR). Published by the Center for Climate and Security, an institute of the Council on Strategic Risks. February, 2021.

Schuler, Barbara. Environmental and climate change in South and Southeast Asia : how are local cultures coping? / edited by Barbara Schuler. Leiden, Netherlands : Brill, 2014

Shook, Bryana. “Challenges Linger Three Years after Fatal Dam Collapse in Mariana.” Wilson Center. December 13, 2018. <>

Sikkink, Kathryn. “Latin America's Protagonist Role in Human Rights.” Sur International Journal On Human Rights, Dec 2015, Vol.12(22), (2015): 207-219

Teitel, Ruti. Humanity's Law. New York: OUP. 2016.

Teitel, Ruti.” Transitional Justice Genealogy”, 16 HARv. HUM. RTs J. 69, (2003): 69-94.

Tladi, Dire. “The African Union and the International Criminal Court : the battle for the soul of international law : Africa and the International Criminal Court.” South African Yearbook of International Law Vol. 34, No. 1 , 1 Jan, (2009): 57-69.

Uddin, Kamal. “Climate Change and Global Environmental Politics: North-South Divide.” Environmental Policy and Law, Jun 2017, Vol.47(3/4), (2017): 106-114.

Vilela, Pedro Rafael. “O que significa a investigação do Tribunal Penal Internacional contra Bolsonaro?” Operamundi, UOL, 18 de dez de 2020. <>

Wachenfeld, Margaret. Extracting Good Practices. A Guide for Governments and Partners to Integrate Environment and Human Rights into the Governance of the Mining Sector. UNDP, 2018. <>

Warn, Elizabeth and Adamo, Susana B. “The Impact of Climate Change: Migration and Cities in South America.” WMO. Bulletin nº : Vol 63 (2), 2014. <>

Watts, Jonathan. “Jair Bolsonaro claims NGOs behind Amazon forest fire surge – but provides no evidence.” The Guardian, 21 Aug 2019. < >

Werrell, Caitlin and Femia, Francesco . “R2P2. The Responsibility to Prepare and Prevent: A Climate Security Governance Framework for the 21st Century.” The Center for Climate and Security. October 2019. <>

Woodward, Ayilin. “The "lungs of the planet" are burning.” World Economic Forum. 22 Aug 2019. <>